top of page
  • Neighborhood Plumber

Gas vs. Electric Water Heater: Pros and Cons

gas electric water heater

When it's time to choose a water heater, the decision between gas and electric models is more than just hot water. It's about efficiency, cost, and what fits your home's needs.

Both have their advantages and drawbacks, and understanding these can save you money and ensure you never have to take a cold shower unless you want to.

Key Takeaways

  • Gas water heaters usually have higher initial costs but lower operational costs compared to electric models.

  • Electric water heaters are typically cheaper to install and may have higher energy efficiency ratings.

  • Gas heaters heat water faster and have a quicker recovery rate, which is crucial for larger households.

  • Electric water heaters are more sustainable and may be the only option for homes without a gas line.

  • Long-term costs, energy efficiency, and environmental impact should all factor into your decision-making process.

Heating Your Home's Water: Making the Right Choice

Choosing the right water heater is crucial. It's a long-term investment that affects your daily comfort and your utility bills. To make an informed decision, you'll need to consider various factors, including the availability of energy sources in your area, the size of your household, and your environmental concerns.

Quick Guide: Gas vs. Electric Water Heaters

Let's break it down simply: gas water heaters use natural gas or propane to heat water, while electric water heaters use electricity. Your choice might be influenced by the availability of natural gas in your area or your preference for a more environmentally friendly option.

How to Decide: Factors Influencing Your Choice

Several factors will sway your decision between gas and electric water heaters. These include your home's existing infrastructure, your budget for upfront costs and ongoing utility expenses, and how quickly you need your water heated.

We'll explore these considerations in detail to help you make the best choice for your home.

The ABCs of Gas Water Heaters

Gas water heaters are known for their quick heating ability and are a common choice for larger families. They require a gas line and venting for installation, which can add to the initial cost but may result in lower energy bills in the long run.

Initial Costs and Installation

Gas water heaters can be more expensive upfront. The cost of the unit itself plus the installation, which may include running gas lines and setting up proper venting, can add up. However, these costs can be offset by the lower monthly operating expenses.

Price of Units

The price of a gas water heater varies depending on the size and efficiency of the unit. On average, you might spend anywhere from $300 to $600 for a standard model, with high-efficiency models costing more.

Installation Complexity and Requirements

Installing a gas water heater can be complex. It requires not only a connection to a gas line but also proper venting to the outdoors, which is essential for safety. This can make the installation process longer and more expensive compared to electric models.

Monthly Utility Bills: Gas Heater Operational Costs

Most importantly, the operational costs of gas heaters tend to be lower than electric ones, because natural gas is often less expensive than electricity. However, this varies by region, so it's important to check local energy prices.

Natural Gas Prices

Because natural gas prices are typically lower than electricity rates, operating a gas water heater usually costs less. This can mean significant savings over the life of the heater, especially in areas where gas is readily available and cheap.

Efficiency Ratings

Gas water heaters come with an energy factor (EF) rating, which measures how well the unit converts energy into heat. The higher the EF, the more efficient the heater. Look for models with an EF close to 1 for the best energy savings.

Heating Speed and Recovery Rate

One of the biggest advantages of gas water heaters is their ability to heat water quickly. This is essential for homes with high hot water usage, as it ensures that hot water is available when you need it.

First-Hour Rating Explained

The first-hour rating (FHR) is a measure of how much hot water the heater can supply per hour, starting with a full tank. Gas heaters often have a higher FHR, which means they can deliver more hot water in a shorter amount of time.

Why Recovery Rate Matters

The recovery rate is how quickly the water heater can heat up a new tank of water after the initial supply is depleted. Gas water heaters typically have a faster recovery rate than electric ones, which is a big plus for back-to-back showers or filling large tubs.

Exploring Electric Water Heaters: What You Need to Know

Electric water heaters are a common choice for many homeowners due to their ease of installation and the ubiquity of electricity. They're particularly appealing in areas without natural gas service or for those seeking a more environmentally friendly option.

Upfront Affordability: Evaluating Electric Water Heater Costs

When it comes to purchase prices, electric water heaters often have the edge. They're generally less expensive than their gas counterparts, making them an attractive option for those on a tight budget.

Comparing Purchase Prices

Electric water heaters can range from around $300 to $700 for a typical residential model. The price will vary based on the size and features of the unit, but they're almost always cheaper upfront than gas models.

Understanding Installation Savings

Installation for electric water heaters is usually straightforward and less costly than gas models. There's no need for gas lines or venting systems, which means you could save hundreds of dollars on installation alone.

Long-Term Investment: Electricity Consumption and Bills

While electric water heaters may be cheaper to buy and install, the ongoing cost of electricity can make them more expensive over time. This is especially true in areas where electricity rates are high.

Energy Factor (EF) and What It Means

The energy factor for electric water heaters also plays a crucial role in understanding long-term costs. An EF rating indicates the amount of hot water produced for each unit of fuel consumed over a typical day. The higher the EF, the more efficient the appliance is.

Assessing Your Home's Electricity Rates

Electricity rates can be a game-changer for the cost-effectiveness of your water heater. You'll need to consider your local electricity costs to truly gauge whether an electric model will be more or less expensive than gas in the long run.

Considerations for Efficiency and Environmental Impact

Electric water heaters can be incredibly efficient, and they're often preferred for their lower environmental impact. With no greenhouse gases emitted on-site, they're a cleaner choice for your home and the planet.

Electric Heater Types and Efficiency

There are several types of electric heaters, including conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump models. Heat pump water heaters, in particular, offer exceptional efficiency by transferring heat from the surrounding air into the water.

Environmental Concerns and Electric Heaters

Electric water heaters are often touted for their environmental benefits. They don't produce on-site emissions like gas heaters do, making them a more eco-friendly choice, especially if your electricity comes from renewable sources.

gas electric water heater

Side-by-Side: Comparing Gas and Electric Water Heaters Directly

Now that we've covered the basics of both gas and electric water heaters, let's put them head-to-head to see how they stack up in various categories.

Cost Comparison in the Short and Long Run

When weighing the costs of gas versus electric water heaters, it's essential to consider both the short-term and long-term financial implications. This includes the initial purchase price, installation costs, and ongoing monthly bills.

Breaking Down the Total Cost of Ownership

The total cost of ownership for a water heater includes the purchase price, installation fees, and the cost of energy over the appliance's lifespan. While gas heaters typically cost more upfront, they often lead to lower energy bills.

Electric heaters, with their lower initial costs but potentially higher utility rates, can become more expensive over time.

Efficiency Battle: Gas vs. Electric

Efficiency is a critical factor when choosing a water heater. It affects not only your wallet but also your environmental footprint. Let's delve into the efficiency of gas and electric models.

Decoding Efficiency Terminology

Understanding efficiency starts with knowing the terms. The energy factor (EF) measures a water heater's overall efficiency based on the amount of hot water produced per unit of fuel consumed. The higher the EF, the more efficient the heater is.

Actual Efficiency in Practice

While EF is important, real-world efficiency can be influenced by many factors, including usage patterns and maintenance. Gas water heaters generally have lower EF ratings than electric ones, but they can heat water faster and are often less expensive to operate due to lower gas prices.

Meeting Your Hot Water Needs

Choosing the right water heater isn't just about cost and efficiency; it's also about meeting your household's hot water needs. Let's look at how gas and electric heaters perform in this regard.

Analyzing Household Consumption Patterns

How much hot water your household uses is a key consideration. Larger families or homes with greater hot water demands may benefit from the quick heating and recovery rates of gas water heaters, while smaller households might find electric models to be adequate and more cost-effective.

Sizing Up the Right Water Heater for Your Home

It's not just about choosing between gas and electric; it's also about selecting the right size. A water heater that's too small won't meet your hot water needs, while one that's too large will unnecessarily increase your energy bills.

Consider the number of bathrooms and people in your home, and consult with a professional to determine the right capacity, typically measured in gallons.

Space Considerations and Installation Logistics

Space is another critical factor. Gas water heaters might need more room for safe operation due to their ventilation requirements. Electric models are usually more compact and can fit in tighter spaces, including closets and corners, without the need for venting.

Understanding Space Requirements

Before you purchase a water heater, measure the space where it will be installed. Make sure there's enough room for installation and maintenance. Gas water heaters often require additional space around them to ensure proper ventilation and safety.

Professional vs. DIY Installation

When it comes to installation, unless you have significant experience with plumbing and gas or electrical systems, it's best to hire a professional. Improper installation can lead to a host of problems, from reduced efficiency to safety hazards.

Sealing the Deal: Selecting the Best Water Heater for Your Home

After considering all the factors, it's time to make your choice. Whether you go with gas or electric, ensure the model you choose fits your home's needs, energy goals, and budget.

Evaluating Your Current Setup

Take a good look at your current water heating setup. If you already have a gas line installed, a gas water heater might make more sense. For homes solely with electricity, or for those looking to reduce their carbon footprint, an electric model could be the way to go.

Forecasting Future Requirements and Changes

Think about any changes you expect in your household. If you plan to grow your family or if you anticipate higher water usage in the future, make sure your new water heater can handle the increased demand.

Why Consultation with a Professional Matters

Consulting with a professional can provide you with insights specific to your situation. They can help you understand the local codes and regulations, suggest the best models for your home, and provide an accurate estimate of installation costs.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Is Upgrading to a High-Efficiency Water Heater Worth the Cost?

Upgrading to a high-efficiency water heater can lead to significant savings over time, especially if your current model is old or inefficient. High-efficiency models use less energy to heat water, which can lower your monthly bills and reduce your environmental impact.

Can I Change My Water Heater from Gas to Electric (or Vice Versa)?

Yes, you can change your water heater from gas to electric or vice versa, but it's not always simple or cost-effective. You'll need to consider the availability of gas or electricity, the cost of installation, and any necessary changes to your home's infrastructure.

What Maintenance is Required for Gas and Electric Water Heaters?

Maintenance is key to extending the life of your water heater. Gas models require checking the venting system, pilot light, and thermocouple, while electric models need their heating elements and thermostats inspected. Flushing the tank annually to remove sediment is important for both types.

How Long Do Water Heaters Typically Last?

On average, water heaters last between 8 and 12 years. However, this lifespan can vary based on the quality of the unit, the hardness of your water, and how well the heater is maintained.

gas electric water heater


bottom of page